My heroic SH group wasn't eager to do the side pulls with the gladiators. I convinced them and on the third group savagery dropped and I won the roll. They saw no point in doing the last pull, but again, I convinced them. It dropped again and the other enchanter got it. Then the chest had a BoE blue healing shield.
Kargath down, no fist. We missed the timer by maybe 5 minutes but at least I got the quest done. :(