Slopes are bad walls

| Friday, January 25, 2013
Few things annoy me in games as much as those slopes that are just barely too steep to climb.  Are they there because of bad terrain design?  Is it a wall disguised as terrain?

I greatly dislike it when my character is forced around in a game.  Crowd control is one form.  Stupidity-based trap quests are another (can't I just shoot him now?).  And then there are the slopes.  You can walk for a little while down, and then it gets steep and pulls you.  You backpedal, jump, turn around and run up, crouch, stand, nothing works as the gravity inevitably pulls you downward.  This isn't a part of progress through a map; you can just run back around another way.  It's instead just an irritant.

Not as bad, but still bad, are the map edges.  With plenty of disk space and a desire to create a sense of place, developers like to put things beyond the edges of the map, usually more terrain and maybe some buildings.  The explorer wants to check them out.  If there is a wall, then they can see the wall, think it is lame, but recognize that not every game is Minecraft and so the map must end somewhere.  But the slope... maybe it can be climbed.  At places it can, though not all the way.  So you go up and up and one missed step and you're sliding back down.  Can I go there or not!?

I should be clear, a sufficiently steep slope becomes okay.  A cliff is clearly impassable and does not create this problem.

4 comments:

vanillabri said...

Especially annoying in a game like GW2, where attaining apparently unreachable areas is it's own minigame. It leads to no end of double-guessing as to whether or not a slope is meant to be climbed, with the only giveaway being whether or not there's a vista waypoint at the top.

Klepsacovic said...

I wonder if it would work to have some sort of difference in texture, subtle, so that we can recognize impassable terrain without it having a glowing sign on it.

Anonymous said...

One thing that always peeved me about WoW is the fact that I am able to attack a monster from range and they can run straight up a slope that I am somehow unable to run up.

Klepsacovic said...

Worse might be, if they can't run up it, they get to magically avoid all damage.

Post a Comment

Comments in posts older than 21 days will be moderated to prevent spam. Comments in posts younger than 21 days will be checked for ID.

Powered by Blogger.